Infant Inserts: Good or Bad?

September 12, 2016

Just a few years ago, there were very few options on the market for baby carriers. These days, babywearers are spoilt for choice! If you’re planning to invest in a structured (buckle) baby carrier, you have SO many options…

  • Canvas vs Woven Wrap Fabric
  • Convertible front, back, hip, outward facing carriers
  • Variety of hood styles
  • Padding options
  • Crossed straps
  • Lumbar support
  • Padded or apron waist
  • Extendable and cinchable panels
  • Pockets
  • Zips
  • Velcro
  • Ties

And finally…

  • Infant insert vs built in adjustability for newborns

 Of all of the above options, I would say that the last point will have the biggest impact on comfort and useability if you’re buying for a small baby or newborn.

structured carry features infographic

Let’s cut to the chase… newborn inserts are generally best avoided for a number of reasons. Curious as to why? Read on!


Why You Should Avoid Infant Inserts

--> They’re Fiddly

When you have a small, floppy, or squirming baby, it is sometimes pretty hard to wrangle them into things, whether it’s a nappy, a onesie, a pair of socks, or a baby carrier! The first time I used a structured baby carrier, even though it didn’t require an infant insert, it was a bit of a learning curve – it sort of felt like there were buckles and straps everywhere! Adding the insert into the mix would have definitely reduced my chances of getting it right the first go and probably giving up.

--> They’re Hot

Unless you’re in the middle of winter (here in Australia), an infant insert is probably going to overheat your baby. Some parents say that their babies who run hot tend to overheat even during winter! The padding and extra fabric reduces airflow and can result in a very sweaty baby (and carer) And this normally means lots of crying.

--> They Add Extra Bulk When Travelling

An insert is just one more thing you’d have to bring along. Baby stuff takes up enough space as it is! Why go for more bulk if you don’t need to?

--> It’s An Extra Expense

Babies are expensive! In addition to buying your carrier, if it requires an infant insert, you might be looking at another $50 to be able to carry your infant or small baby in it until they get bigger. For the same price (minus the extra expense of the insert), you could buy a carrier with one built in!

--> You Might Be Tempted to Skip It

Because infant inserts are annoying, bulky, and expensive, a lot of the time, people decide to skip them altogether. Instead of the legitimate insert, some people add their own makeshift “insert” (perhaps a rolled up towel), fold the waistband (against manufacturer guidelines) or simply over-extend their baby’s legs. This can especially happen when people buy their carriers secondhand, without the original packaging and instructions. Not only is this dangerous (slumping and suffocation risk), but it can also be annoying for the wearer and uncomfortable for the baby.

--> Your Baby Might HATE It

Babies all have reflexes on the bottom of their feet. They have them there so they can ‘push’ themselves out of the womb. In the early weeks, babies can often still be sensitive to this so putting pressure on the feet may cause a baby to push against it. Unfortunately, this is the position an insert requires baby to be placed in. Certain babies will be more sensitive to this than others and may cry and try to push themselves up off the carrier or just be unsettled.


So Why Do People Buy a Carrier WITH an Insert?

I find that people usually only buy carriers that require infant inserts if they are unaware of the range of options available to them. It seems that most of the mainstream baby shops only stock popular brands that require the inserts and employees are usually offered incentives and bonuses to sell certain carriers rather than meeting the needs of each individual customer. Many new parents don’t realise that it might be a better idea to shop at a specialty babywearing store, rather than limiting their options to mainstream brands.

What Are the Best Structured Carriers for Newborns?

Fortunately, there are plenty of options on the market today that are perfect from newborn (3.5kg+) to toddler, without requiring an extra insert. So you can save money, space, and avoid the hassle! I can recommend the Manduca and Kokadi Flip & TaiTai (baby size is suitable from newborn), both of which we have in stock (and available through AfterPay). There are also lots of other options, so do your research to find out what’s best for you.

If in doubt, head to a local babywearing meet. You’ll usually find a wide variety of carriers that you can play with and figure out what fits your needs best before you buy.

If you're looking for a little less structure, the Fidella Meh Dai FlyTai is a fantastic option for newborns that grows with them to toddlerhood. Soft, breathable, and adjustable (and very pretty!).


What Now?

Wearing your baby is an amazing parenting tool, and while choosing the right carrier is going to help, if you’re not sure on what to buy, just jump right in. And if you already have a carrier with an infant insert, that’s fine too, if you’re finding it comfortable and it’s working for you. Don’t miss out on those precious cuddles! If you decide your carrier isn’t right, you can always re-sell it to someone else who will love it. Just don’t stress because carrying your child should be simply bliss!


Happy babywearing!


P.S. If you found this article handy, please go ahead and SHARE!


Brooke Maree © 2017 All Rights Reserved

Being a copycat or blatantly stealing is never cool. There is a fine line between inspiration and stealing, so please be respectful, honest, and full of integrity when sharing this piece of writing or using its information. Many hours of work, planning, and editing goes into our pieces to ensure the highest quality first-hand information. Any of our work that is plagiarised will eventually be found and brought to attention. That being said, you are ALWAYS welcome to share our content, as long as you attribute and link back to the source. xxx

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.

Also in News

Babywearing and Hip Dysplasia

October 18, 2021

Many parents wonder if they can still use a baby carrier if their baby is in a brace and being treated for Hip Dysplasia. The short answer is usually always yes! Which is great news. It’s about finding a suitable carrier style that is comfortable for you and your baby whilst they are in the brace.

View full article →

Toddler Baby Carriers

May 02, 2021

There's always a point when your toddler or preschooler's legs get tired and they just want you to pick them up. Thankfully there's many baby carrier options out there that I can tell you about! And there's many more benefits to carrying your toddler too, not just saving those tired legs! 

View full article →

What are TICKS Babywearing Safety Guidelines?

February 05, 2021

Saftey is the #1 priority when carrying your baby no matter the age of your baby or how experienced you are. You need to do a TICKS safety check every time you set your baby up in your carrier, wrap, or sling.

View full article →