Top 13 Babywearing Myths BUSTED!

August 08, 2016

Babywearing is still something of a new concept to much of the Western World. Even though it’s been around for centuries in most parts of the world, here in Australia, a pram is still very much the norm.

While many more parents are choosing to have a baby carrier on hand, there are still plenty of parents (and other members of the public) who don’t see a baby carrier as an essential tool, or even think they may be harmful to a baby’s development.

Myths like this can spread quickly in the community and sometimes mean that parents and babies who might have benefited from this amazing tool then end up missing out! So it’s time we did some mythbusting! Here are some of the top babywearing myths I’ve come across recently…

  1.  You’ll spoil your baby if they’re always carried

Actually, you can’t spoil a baby at all. They’re little for such a short amount of time, and one of their greatest needs (not just wants!) is to be held close and secure to you. Spoiling a baby by loving and comforting them is a strange myth that came about in the mid 20th century… one that has been well and truly busted by today’s professionals.

  1. Your baby won’t learn to be independent if you carry them constantly

Attachment parenting (which includes carrying and wearing your baby) has been proven to have the opposite effect. Babies that form a secure attachment learn to become independent at a pace that they are comfortable with, leading to greater independence, stability, lowered stress, and the ability to cope better with new situations.

  1. Your baby needs to learn how to nap in a cot – napping in the carrier might teach them bad habits

If napping in the carrier isn’t working for your family, then sure, try to transition them to a cot or bed. But if your baby naps in the carrier, it can actually be a convenient way to settle them while you’re out and about or just getting the housework done. It’s only a *bad* habit if you decide that it is. And don’t worry – it won’t be long and your baby will be a small toddler or child who prefers to nap in bed.

  1. You must really overheat your baby in that carrier

Yes, sometimes a carrier can be hot. This can depend on the materials it is made of and the design of the carrier. But usually if you’re going to be in a hot climate, you choose something suitable for it (just like your clothing). You can definitely still wear your baby in the heat of summer without overheating them (see our article on Babywearing During Summer).

  1. Carrying your baby in a carrier will harm their hips

When you have a little person, whose joints are still developing and growing, it is so important to be careful not to position them in a way that is unnatural for them. Situations where baby’s legs are held in a straightened position (tightly swaddled, jolly jumpers, etc.) for long periods could be damaging to the not yet developed hip socket. Fortunately, when your baby is seated knee-to-knee in a baby carrier, it’s a totally natural position for them, and won’t harm their hips.

Different baby carriers will sit baby in a different position. Aim for the photo on the right which shows the natural 'M' position with knees at belly button height. Photo credit: Manduca EU

  1. Your baby didn’t like the (one) carrier you’ve tried, so they don’t like to be carried

Just because you’ve had a bad experience with a carrier, doesn’t mean you or your baby won’t get to enjoy babywearing! It might have been a range of factors leading to the experience (see my article on "My Baby Hates The Baby Carrier!"), but it definitely doesn’t mean that your baby hates being in all carriers.

  1. Your baby will suffocate in there – are you sure they can breathe?

I was asked this question myself by a concerned older lady when my little one was sleeping on my chest with the hood over his head. I think she meant well! However, if you know about safe babywearing practices (upright, chin off chest, airways clear, kissable head, etc.) and stay attune to your little one, you’ll be very much aware of their movements and breathing. Babies have (in the past) tragically suffocated when parents have used carriers in the cradle position, which is unsafe. This is because the cradle position goes against T.I.C.K.S guidelines (shown below) of having the baby’s chin off chest to keep airway clear. In an upright position, this won’t happen.

babywearing ticks

Credit: School of Babywearing

  1. Those baby carriers really hurt your back and shoulders

Some baby carriers can be uncomfortable, yes! But not all! In fact, most of them are really well designed with padding in just the right places. If your carrier is hurting, it might not be fitted correctly, or something else might be better suited to your frame or your baby’s size. Don’t put up with a sore back or shoulders – ask a consultant for help or head to a babywearing meet to try on some alternatives.

  1. What a great idea! Wish it was invented for when my kids were little.

Although it is tempting to take credit for the amazing “idea” of wearing my baby, it certainly wasn’t mine. Actually, babywearing has been around for about as long as babies have existed. For parents in the Western world, the use of baby carriers is still a fairly recent tool. Depending on the type of baby carrier you are using, its design and inspiration may have originated in Asia, Africa, South America, Europe, and other parts of the world.

  1. That must be really difficult

Parenting without a baby carrier is much more difficult, trust me! A few simply YouTube tutorials, and you’ll be on your way! Pulling out a baby carrier or wrap is now one of the easiest things about parenting for me.

  1. Doesn’t your baby need more tummy time?

Tummy time is important to help your little one develop strong muscles and avoid spending too much time lying on their back (like in the cot, pram, car seat, etc). The great thing about babywearing is that it helps with both of those things! Your baby uses their muscles while being worn to compensate for your movements, and their head shape and development isn’t obstructed by a flat surface. So if you’re told that your baby needs more tummy time, please feel free to simply put them in the carrier instead.

  1. My baby will only face outwards

Some parents insist that their baby prefers to face outwards. Maybe you are in the habit of holding your baby that way, or they prefer to watch what’s going on. However, it is generally more comfortable for both of you to have your baby facing inwards. If you plan on babywearing for long periods, you could instead try a hip or back (if your baby is old enough) carry to allow your child to see more of their surroundings.

  1. Your baby can walk – they don’t need to be carried

Just because your little one has learnt how to walk, doesn’t mean they suddenly won’t need to be held close or have cuddles with you. Little legs get tired quickly, little people venture into places that might not be safe, and sometimes the outside world is a bit overwhelming. At these times, a baby carrier is still so handy with a toddler or small child. There are carriers designed with bigger babies and children in mind, so you can still babywear comfortably. Ignore anyone who may tell you that your child is too big!

In summary? Babywearing is awesome! Just about any parent and child can benefit from it, and anyone who tells you otherwise probably hasn’t given it a proper try for themselves.

Celebrate babywearing! One of the most empowering tools to use as a mother. 

Happy babywearing! 

P.S. Help me bust those myths and spread the babywearing love by sharing this article. Together we can normalise babywearing! 

Brooke Maree © 2018 All Rights Reserved

Being a copycat or blatantly stealing is never cool. There is a fine line between inspiration and stealing, so please be respectful, honest, and full of integrity when sharing this piece of writing or using its information. Many hours of work, planning, and editing goes into our pieces to ensure the highest quality first-hand information. Any of our work that is plagiarised will more than likely be found and brought to attention. That being said, you are ALWAYS welcome to share our content, as long as you attribute and link back to the source. xxx

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.

Also in News

Babywearing and Hip Dysplasia

October 18, 2021

Many parents wonder if they can still use a baby carrier if their baby is in a brace and being treated for Hip Dysplasia. The short answer is usually always yes! Which is great news. It’s about finding a suitable carrier style that is comfortable for you and your baby whilst they are in the brace.

View full article →

Toddler Baby Carriers

May 02, 2021

There's always a point when your toddler or preschooler's legs get tired and they just want you to pick them up. Thankfully there's many baby carrier options out there that I can tell you about! And there's many more benefits to carrying your toddler too, not just saving those tired legs! 

View full article →

What are TICKS Babywearing Safety Guidelines?

February 05, 2021

Saftey is the #1 priority when carrying your baby no matter the age of your baby or how experienced you are. You need to do a TICKS safety check every time you set your baby up in your carrier, wrap, or sling.

View full article →